Oddity Archive: Episode 120 – Minidisc

It’s (100% showtune-free) Musical March (read: Audio Geek March, “Musical March” is just a lot catchier) in Archiveland! Let’s kick it off with a little reevaluation of a format that I’ve bashed in the past.

Recording/Playback notes:

(SP Mode)

iPod (AAC @256kbps – ripped from original CD) – emphasizes lossy parts of signal

CD (via ANALOG input) – slightly emphasizes things like tape saturation in original recording, slight rolloff in mid/upper range

CD (IN-SYSTEM DUB) – perfect/near-perfect copy of CD

Radio – slightly lossy, emphasizes lossy parts of signal from stations that stream their content

Cassette – somewhat lossy in mid and upper range

(Further optical tests – CD)

SP Mode – perfect/near-perfect copy of CD

LP2 – akin to moderate-to-high-bitrate mp3

LP4 – akin to low-to-moderate-bitrate mp3

Mono – surprisingly solid (and not lossy) mono folddown of stereo recordings

NOTE: Also did same set of tests via ANALOG inputs—very small notch down in quality.

Further analog-source tests:

(128kbps mp3)

SP Mode – near-perfect duplicate of existing file

LP2 – notch below existing quality

LP4 – very lossy, stereo image almost non-existant

Mono – decent mono folddown—only loss is carried over from original

(Vinyl – mediocre vinyl stock, poor mastering)

SP – definite lossy parts of mid and upper range (much more pronounced in cymbals than any other format)

LP2 – low-to-moderate loss

LP4 – moderate-to-major loss, near-mono (ironically, far less harsh high-end)

Mono – emphasizes high-end distortion

Visit our website at http://www.oddityarchive.com

Social Media:

Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/oddityarchive

Twitter: @oddityarchive

Help out the Archive by making a monthly donation to our Patreon campaign at http://www.patreon.com/oddityarchive